
How Often Do Big Underdogs Win in Football? Upset Rates by League
Big outsiders win less often than their prices imply, and the gap widens as the odds lengthen. Here is where upsets happen, and what backing them blindly costs.
- 13.5%their margin-free priced chance
- −18.1%return at a major bookmaker
- 5.4%of 10.00+ outsiders won
Football is full of shocks, and the bettor's instinct is to chase them. I wanted to test that instinct properly: across 22 European divisions from 2016/17-2025/26, covering 31,183 matches with an underdog at 4.00 or longer, how often does the big outsider actually win, and does the price pay you for the risk?
The short answer is no, not on its own. Underdogs priced 5.00 or longer won 12.0% of 18,392 matches, against a margin-free priced chance of 13.5%, and backing all of them at a major bookmaker returned −18.1%. Everything I publish on my best win-draw-win picks page starts from this baseline: a long price is not value simply because it is long.
01Outsiders win less often than their odds suggest
This chart sets each price band's margin-free implied chance against how often the underdog actually won. In every band the real win rate sits below the price. At 4.00–4.99 the gap is small, 20.4% won against 21.5% priced, but by 7.00–9.99 it is 9.8% against 11.8%, and at 10.00 or longer only 5.4% won against 7.0% priced.
The 95% ranges are tight, ±0.7 or ±0.8, so this is not noise. The pattern is the classic favourite-longshot bias: the market overrates the outsider, and it overrates it most where the odds are longest.
View the data: big underdogs: priced vs won
| Priced (margin removed) | Actually won | 95% range | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.00–4.99 (12,791 matches) | 21.5% | 20.4% | ±0.7 |
| 5.00–6.99 (10,019 matches) | 16.7% | 15.5% | ±0.7 |
| 7.00–9.99 (4,756 matches) | 11.8% | 9.8% | ±0.8 |
| 10.00+ (3,617 matches) | 7.0% | 5.4% | ±0.7 |
Fair odds tell the same story. A 10.00+ outsider would need to be priced around 18.64 to break even on these results, and even the 4.00–4.99 band needs roughly 4.89. Notice too how often these sides draw: 26.4% at 4.00–4.99 and 23.3% at 5.00–6.99. For a modest underdog, the draw is a serious result, not an afterthought.
02Flat-staking every big underdog loses money at any price
Here is the cost in plain terms. A one-unit stake on every underdog returned −10.7% at 4.00–4.99 with a major bookmaker, sliding to −12.5%, then −21.6%, then −28.8% at 10.00 or longer. The longer you go, the worse it gets.
Taking the best available price cuts the damage sharply, to −4.4% in the shortest band and −15.7% in the longest, but it never turns positive. Those best prices were not always obtainable in practice, and stake limits apply, so treat that second bar as a ceiling rather than a realistic result.
View the data: backing every big underdog
| At a major bookmaker | At best available price | |
|---|---|---|
| 4.00–4.99 | −10.7% | −4.4% |
| 5.00–6.99 | −12.5% | −5.4% |
| 7.00–9.99 | −21.6% | −13.3% |
| 10.00+ | −28.8% | −15.7% |
My reading from the trading desk: price shopping roughly halves the bleed but cannot fix a negative-expectation position. If you bet outsiders at all, the shorter bands and the best price are the least bad place to stand.
03Second divisions produce upsets, Primeira Liga suppresses them
Upset rates vary by league more than the overall figure suggests. Ligue 2 led at 15.4% of 500 matches for 5.00+ underdogs, with a return of −6.2%, and second tiers dominate the top of the list: the 2. Bundesliga, Serie B and National League all sit at 14.2%, with the Championship at 13.8%.
At the bottom, the Primeira Liga produced just 8.4% across 1,156 matches and a return of −31.9%. Top flights with a dominant elite, Greece and Scotland included, cluster near the bottom. Flatter, more competitive divisions give outsiders more room.
Top 8 and bottom 6 leagues with 150+ such matches; match counts in brackets.
View the data: where 5.00+ underdogs win most
| Win rate of underdogs priced 5.00 or longer | |
|---|---|
| Ligue 2 (500) | 15.4% |
| 2. Bundesliga (330) | 14.2% |
| Serie B (577) | 14.2% |
| National League (811) | 14.2% |
| Segunda División (791) | 14.0% |
| Scottish League Two (266) | 13.9% |
| Championship (974) | 13.8% |
| League Two (593) | 13.5% |
| Bundesliga (1,007) | 11.4% |
| Serie A (1,526) | 11.1% |
| Eredivisie (1,221) | 10.6% |
| Scottish Premiership (814) | 9.5% |
| Super League Greece (789) | 9.3% |
| Primeira Liga (1,156) | 8.4% |
The main caveat belongs here. Long-odds returns swing heavily on a handful of results, and a few upsets can move a league's figure by several points, so Ligue 2's −6.2% is a hint about where to look, not a profitable system.
04Home or away barely changes how big underdogs finish
I expected home advantage to matter for outsiders. It hardly does once the price is 5.00 or longer. Away underdogs won 11.9% and drew 19.8% across 14,314 matches; home underdogs won 12.5% and drew 19.4% across 4,078.
The market already builds venue into the price, so a home outsider at 5.00 is not secretly stronger than an away one at the same number. The real split is in the draw: roughly one in five of these matches ends level either way, which matters if you are weighing a double chance against a straight win bet.
View the data: home or away: how 5.00+ underdogs finish
| Underdog won | Draw | Underdog lost | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Away underdog (14,314) | 11.9% | 19.8% | 68.3% |
| Home underdog (4,078) | 12.5% | 19.4% | 68.1% |
1X2 checklist
- Check the price band first. Outsiders at 4.00–4.99 returned −4.4% at the best price, while 10.00+ shots returned −15.7%. Anything longer than about 7.00 needs an unusually strong reason.
- Always take the best price. Moving from a major bookmaker to the best available price cut the 5.00+ loss from −18.1% towards −9.5%. Never accept the first number you see on an outsider.
- Weigh the league and draw. Ligue 2 outsiders won 15.4% against 8.4% in the Primeira Liga. With draws near 20% for 5.00+ underdogs, ask whether double chance suits your view better than the straight win.
Quick answers
How often do big underdogs win in football?
In this study, underdogs priced 5.00 or longer won 12.0% of 18,392 European matches. Outsiders at 10.00 or longer won just 5.4%.
Is it profitable to back football underdogs?
Not blindly. Backing every 5.00+ underdog returned −18.1% at a major bookmaker and −9.5% even at the best available price.
Which league has the most football upsets?
Among leagues with enough matches, Ligue 2 had the highest 5.00+ upset rate at 15.4%, while the Primeira Liga had the lowest at 8.4%.
